Showing posts with label Articles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Articles. Show all posts

Monday, November 07, 2011

The Secret Wonder of a Brain on Music

An excerpt of David Eagleman's Incognito: The Secret Lives of the Brain in Discover Magazine got me thinking about how much the workings of the music-making process might be something just underneath the surface of consciousness, something we can honor without knowing exactly how we actually do it:
The ability to remember motor acts like changing lanes is called procedural memory, and it is a type of implicit memory—meaning that your brain holds knowledge of something that your mind cannot explicitly access. Riding a bike, tying your shoes, typing on a keyboard, and steering your car into a parking space while speaking on your cell phone are examples of this. You execute these actions easily but without knowing the details of how you do it. You would be totally unable to describe the perfectly timed choreography with which your muscles contract and relax as you navigate around other people in a cafeteria while holding a tray, yet you have no trouble doing it. This is the gap between what your brain can do and what you can tap into consciously.  
The concept of implicit memory has a rich, if little-known, tradition. By the early 1600s, RenĂ© Descartes had already begun to suspect that although experience with the world is stored in memory, not all memory is accessible. The concept was rekindled in the late 1800s by the psychologist Hermann Ebbinghaus, who wrote that “most of these experiences remain concealed from consciousness and yet produce an effect which is significant and which authenticates their previous existence.”  
To the extent that consciousness is useful, it is useful in small quantities, and for very particular kinds of tasks. It’s easy to understand why you would not want to be consciously aware of the intricacies of your muscle movement, but this can be less intuitive when applied to your perceptions, thoughts, and beliefs, which are also final products of the activity of billions of nerve cells.

How much of the following delicate musical skills are processes that are completely conscious, and how much are they skills that, once learned, we are able to access from our mental toolkit just underneath the horizon of conscious thought while we focus on what's going on in the present moment:

  • Following a singer's vocal line from the piano, being in the present moment so much that we can react to their every nuance, hesitation, and forward motion based on the play of consonants and vowels.
  • Following a violinist's bow, either watching or merely listening, and being able to tell exactly when, in the space of a microsecond, the bow slows down, stops, and changes direction for routine bow changes. Being able to perceive these bow changes is integral to being able to play together with a string player, especially a very good one who freely uses rubato.
  • Being able to walk the fine line between the composer's intentions and our own musical instinct.
  • Becoming so comfortable with the technical demands of a work that the hours upon hours of work spent learning the notes allows us to make the work a part of us while we concentrate on the present moment of the music. 
  • Being able to sight read a piece of music for the first time, making on-the-fly decisions about quality of sound, phrasing, and musical style.
What are some musical abilities that you've worked hard for, achieved, and learned to rely on once you internalized them?




Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Assorted Links for Tuesday

From ChoralNet, a number of people have contributed to a list of Qualities Expected in a Choral Accompanist.

In the February 2002 Creative Keyboard, Per Danielsson talks about Accompanying a Singer from the jazz pianist's perspective.

Vocal coaches don't just work in the classical field, they are also active in genres such as pop and country, with plenty of advice on how to succeed in American Idol and other reality TV competitions.

Don't like pop music? Read about Melissa Cross and her experience coaching death metal singers.

Times of India reports on the experiences of tabla and harmonium accompanists in India which seem strikingly similar to those of us in the West.

Wednesday, July 04, 2007

Audition Strategies for Singers

Another wonderful discovery this week was Boston Singers Resource, which contains an enormous amount of information both at the free and subscriber level. One of the articles on the site is Audition Strategies for Singers, a list of general audition guidelines compiled by Beth McLeod of Opera by the Bay, Scott Brummit of Longwood Opera, and BSR director Lynn Shane.

A few highlights of the list:

* DO NOT give a pianist unbound single pages.
* DO NOT give your pianist music that is wrapped in clear, shiny plastic. It often creates a glare from lighting.
* If repertoire is your choice, DO research the company and the upcoming works that you are auditioning for.


About that last one--when playing auditions for a certain company in Toronto a few months ago I was shocked at just how few people in two full days of auditions actually bothered to research the company and what they do. This is extremely important for smaller niche companies that have a specific mandate.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

What Do You Look For In An Accompanist?

An article by Michelle Bennett entitled What Do You Look For in an Accompanist? examines some of the criteria that go into a singer choosing a pianist. This is definitely required reading for all singers and pianists, and here are some thoughts on Michelle's list based on my own experience:

  • Ditto on professionalism as a deciding factor. I recall talking to an exasperated singer asking for pianists I could refer her to. ________'s words: "I don't even care if they're great players, as long as they're reliable." Our art is often one where reliability and consistency are often valued more than mere genius.
  • Being able to comment intelligently on matters of poetry and drama as it relates to the music is another ability that is highly valued.
  • Being able to comment on suitability of repertoire is also something that singers need, although not every pianist is at the stage where they know voices enough to be able to do this. When talking rep with singers, often there are some tough choices to be made. When I was younger, I used to hold my tongue and play the diplomat when working with singers preparing unsuitable rep (18-year-old tenors singing Nessun dorma, 17-year-old sopranos singing The Trees on the Mountain). Now I just say what I feel and damn the torpedoes. If singers don't agree with my opinions they can choose to work with someone else.
  • Singers also need to find a pianist/accompanist/vocal coach/recital partner whom they get along with. There are so many elements to perfect in the art of singing, much of it dealing with integrating work in one's own body, and how much more pleasant is the experience working with a pianist if they are a positive force.
The singers who can potentially get the most out of Michelle's list are developing singers at the pre-college level who stand to gain the most working with pianists and coaches that are genuinely knowledgeable about the singer's art, thus speeding the process of artistic development (and improving one's chances of landing a spot in a top-flight school).

Sunday, June 24, 2007

The Two Most Boring Words In the English Language?

Anne Midgette writes in today's New York Times about whether or not chamber music needs redefining in order to reach a wider audience.

Link (Via artsJournal)

Sunday, May 20, 2007

Alexis Diamond on the opera creation process

Alexis Diamond wrote a fascinating article entitled "Making Contemporary Opera Work" in the Summer 2006 edition of Notations, the journal of the Ontario region of the Canadian Music Centre. A graduate of the 2003 Tapestry Composer/Librettist Laboratory, she then embarked upon a fellowship from the Canadian Opera Creation Program to study the opera creation process. An excerpt from Alexis' article:

What was so amazingly revealed through my research was a series of consistent themes, no matter the era, the opera, or the team.

I was immediately struck by the fact that so many of the operas written by those I interviewed treated historical subjects, events or figures – a fact which links these new works to the traditional repertoire. Obviously, the story of an opera has to be large enough in scope to sustain the largesse of the voices, the music and the staging, but also as Don Hannah, librettist of Facing South, said, the “large emotional content.” Keith Turnbull’s theory is that the historical dimension gives both partners an external, objective referent that grounds the idea and subsequent discussions of the work.

Saturday, May 12, 2007

Resource Roundup: Avoiding burnout at the busiest time of the year

This is the time when everyone seems to be going nuts with the recital, audition, and exam crunch. Here are some ideas from the productivity blogosphere about how to stay fresh:

If you didn't think things were busy enough, Everyday Wonderland has a list of 5 Ideas for Stressful Living to make things even worse. I presume that if you don't heed this advice you can avoid undue gnashing of teeth when navigating the peak season... (Thanks, Valerie)


--------------------


On the positive side, Slow Leadership has a list of 12 ways to prevent burnout. I like #11:

Keep a sense of humor. Your worries and fears are really funny, if you look at them from the outside. What’s the worst that could happen to you? You could die, but that would end all your worries for good. You could be fired, but if the job is driving you nuts that’s a benefit. Take a look around you. Who are the grimmest people you can see? The control-freaks, the over-achievers, the worry-warts, the pocket dictators. Who are the funniest to watch making idiots of themselves? The same list.

--------------------


We are artists. We must develop and move forward even though we're often jumping through hoops for others. Freelance Switch has a post about Staying on top of your game that has some insight on how to maintain your edge and continue your development even when you're in the thick of it:

When you work in a job where you are surrounded by others, or when studying your trade at university, you will feed off other people and naturally push yourself to compete. However as a freelancer, often working alone, you can easily fall into a vacuum where your current level of expertise feels good enough. Give in to this and your service may lose value over time. Unless you have a burning internal urge you may find it helps to put yourself into situations that force you to stay on top.



--------------------


Next, check out this list on Problogger of 5 ways to enhance your creativity, with ideas on how to keep the muse going. Also take a look at the 39 comments (so far) following the post with even move creativity hacks.


--------------------


Finally, you might want to try some of the books in Julia Cameron's celebrated The Artist's Way series, and learn to build a creativity process from the ground up that works for you and can weather the peak season.

(Photo by alexindigo)


Tuesday, December 20, 2005

The Young Collaborative Pianist

What are some possible entrance points for young pianists into the world of collaborative piano? How can their formative first experiences in this field create positive outcomes that will give them the curiousity for further exploration? Joyce Grill in her article Accompanying Skills: Where to Begin? from the September 1998 Piano Pedagogy Forum mentions the idea of team participation that is central to sports, but seemingly discouraged for pianists:

Young students like the idea of "team", of camaraderie. But except for the occasional duet, piano students practice alone and go to their lesson alone. The vocalist or the instrumentalist gets to sing in a choir or play in a band or orchestra, but the piano student goes on alone, never getting to know the joy of making music with others.


She goes on to list several ways that accompanying in various musical settings can develop critical listening skills from musicians of other disciplines.

Susan Keith Gray writes in a similar vein in her article
Summertime Collaborations from the June/July 2004 American Music Teacher. She encourages teachers to do the footwork to get ensembles going at an early stage:

I visited with my local violin colleagues (although most any instrument would work), who were excited and eager to work with me. Much to my surprise, we were able to pair the students quickly. Even in our small town, performance level and age were well matched. For all the teams, we selected appropriate repertoire for informal, short-term goals. As the students began practicing independently, I monitored their progress and determined when they were ready for their first meetings with their partners and with me.


Again, the emphasis is on building team experiences with well-matched partners. It is almost as if the social aspects of the encouter are as important as the musical content. Teachers need to make this element of music-making fun in order to succeed.

Halfway through high school, my interest in piano playing had hit a plateau. I suffered from terrible stage fright, had trouble keeping my focus at the piano, and got the bug of something that I can only describe as pianistic loneliness. Then one September, I was pressed into service as the rehearsal and performance pianist for my high school's musicals in Grades 11 and 12. The impact this had on my life at the keyboard was immediate. I enjoyed incorporating piano playing into working with others on a common goal, enjoyed the shows we put on (Cabaret and Guys and Dolls), and most of all enjoyed the process, which is central to any successful activity in the arts. And although I didn't enter a specific collaborative piano degree program until many years later, the seeds of the spirit of teamwork were sown at an early age, the experience was positive, and it provided a framework for what eventually became a career.

Thursday, December 01, 2005

Them that plays together....

It has been a pleasure reading through the many online issues of the Piano Pedagogy Forum, edited by Scott Price, Jane Magrath, Barbara Fast, and Steve Clark. The variety of the articles encompasses piano pedagogy, performance, technology, style, and history, as well as the collaborative arts.

One of the many articles on collaborative piano in the PPF is the excellent Don't Be Late! Rhythmic Visualization in the Collaborative Musical Ensemble by Scott Price of the University of South Carolina in the May 1999 issue. Here he looks at ways at energizing the rhythmic sense of an ensemble as a route toward solving the details of playing together.

A short quote from his article:

...one of the first things I have my students do is to put down their instruments and take their parts to an area where they have to rely on the visual score and aural visualization of the musical sound. They are forced to read the score and and know what sounds they desire before they touch their instruments. I often require that my students and their partners use nonsense syllables to vocalize their way through the rhythmic gestures of a section or the whole piece. By speaking the rhythm to each other, they are actively communicating the natural rhythm of the piece in a manner that is most natural to themselves.

Tuesday, November 29, 2005

Brooks Smith 1989 interview in Stereophile

In 1989 legendary pianist Brooks Smith made a remarkable reference-quality recording with flutist Gary Woodward on the Stereophile label. Richard Lehnert's interview with Brooks Smith from the September 1989 issue of Stereophile is lovingly preserved on their web site. Here are some highlights:

Lehnert: What was it like to work with Heifetz?
Smith: Wonderful, but he was very demanding. He was a very good pianist, which surprised me, and was very critical of my playing, as he was of his own—as he was of everyone's.

Lehnert: How do you see your role as an accompanist, which some consider a thankless job?
Smith: I've never had anything against helping others put on a good performance, nor have I ever felt slighted in playing the role of an accompanist.
Lehnert: But surely you've been in situations where you've had to play music you don't at all like...?
Smith: Yes, that's true. But as an accompanist, it's part of your job to make it all sound good.

Wednesday, November 23, 2005

Wolfram Rieger interview in Music & Vision

In the online classical music magazine Music & Vision, Tess Crebbin wrote an excellent article entitled Diving into the Music featuring an interview with German pianist and coach Wolfram Rieger. Here is a short excerpt:

TC: Now I understand why you said this is not a job for people who cannot be team players.

WR: A big part of this job is about intuitively knowing what the singer is going to do, so you need a certain amount of sensitivity, to pick up on even the most minute of problems. You have to have good hearing, also. This is not
about the theory-related, analytical sense of hearing that you need in music theory classes. Our kind of hearing goes on at a human-to-human level. You notice: oops, this is going in a direction it shouldn't be going, and then you jump in and do your bit. It becomes a problem if you simply don't notice things like that going on.

The Aria Frequency List

Once again, Kim Witman's Wolf Trap 2006 blog has come up with some fascinating information, this time a list of the frequency of arias that have been offered for the Wolf Trap auditions, subdivided by voice type.

Here are the most offered arias from the list:

Soprano:
Ach, ich fuhl's

Mezzo-soprano:
Must the Winter Come so Soon
Sein wir wieder gut
Smanie implacabili
Va, laisse couler mes larmes

Tenor:
Dies Bildniss

Baritone:
Hai gia vinta la causa

Bass & Bass-Baritone
I'm a Lonely Man, Susannah
Aprite un po'
Madamina
O du mein holder Abenstern

Of course, merely offering the most popular of arias in an audition is no guarantee of success, nor is offering unknown arias. What lists cannot tell for individual singers is how appropriate certain arias can be for once's voice, temperament, age, and goals. Singers I have worked with have found audition success (or lack thereof) with both the most conservative of arias and with brilliant but unknown arias.

What I find most fascinating in the Aria Frequency List is looking down the list at the not-so-well-known arias, many of which will definitely be on my list of things to discover.

-----

Perhaps another type of list for someone to compile would be a list of arias offered by singers that actually are hired by companies, so that one can see which arias are the ones with the highest success rates.

Saturday, November 19, 2005

You're a what?

Vocal coach? Collaborative pianist? Voice teacher? Accompanist?

Here are two articles othat describe the overlap between different aspects of the collaborative profession.

"Do You Teach Voice?" The Gray Area of Vocal Coaching by Sylvie Beaudette, Eastman School of Music

What is Vocal Coaching? by Timothy Hoekman, Florida State University

Don't over-medicate the patient

From Lucie Renard's 1999 article in La Scena Musicale entitled "The Accompanist: The Unsung Hero?"

"An accompanist shares many traits with an anaesthetist. He generally has studied longer than the surgeon and must constantly stay alert to prevent an unpredictable disaster, but when all is said and done, the surgeon (like the soloist) gets all of the credit."

Thursday, November 17, 2005

Am I Too Soft?

Here's another quote from Kim Pensinger Witman's Wolf Trap 2006 blog from the 4th day of auditions in New York:

"I know that it’s comforting to bring an accompanist who knows you and who knows your repertoire. But please don’t bring someone who does you a disservice. It happened a few times this week. Both my colleague and I are coaches, and we know when a singer is struggling to drag his or her pianist up to tempo. (Or fighting to slow down a runaway train.) The majority of singers who bring accompanists do not fall into this category, but sadly, the singers who do make this mistake are often the very ones who can ill afford a liability like that."

I most definitely agree with Ms. Witman. However, there are those that disagree. I recall discussing this very issue with a coach of many years experience playing for opera companies and auditions. He argued that voice auditions exist primarily to show beauty of voice, suitability for hiring, and reactions under pressure. His line of reasoning continued that If a singer shows up with a pianist that they have rehearsed with, the audition shows that they have rehearsed and can work together, but not enough about a singer's suitability. Thus, even if a singer performs an audition with a pianist that is inappropriate for them, they should be able to rise above the crowd if they possess the abilities to transcend the occasion. It has been said that some German companies and agents hire second-rate audition pianists for precisely this reason--to see how the singers will react in a difficult situation.

I disagree with this contrarian line of thinking. There is simply too much at stake in a voice audition (transportation time and costs, clothing, parking, hiring a pianist, only having one shot, etc.) too accept anything less than the highest level of playing from the pianist. And I think that the quality of ensemble between singer and pianist results in a higher quality of sung performance and reflects positively to those hearing the auditions and making the casting choices (one can only hope).

Sunday, November 13, 2005

Charles Rosen on "dislocation" in piano playing

Link to article

Charles Rosen, in Section 1 of his review of Robert Philip's Performing Music in the Age of Recording in the NY Review of Books, talks about the purpose and history of "dislocation" in piano playing. For those not familiar with the term, dislocation is the practice of sounding the right hand slightly after the left hand for expressive purposes, popular in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, but currently out of favor (I concur). In the piano field, it is also referred to pejoratively as "da-dum" playing.

Rosen talks about the historical basis for this style of playing, its advantages and disadvantages. To pinpoint the section of the article, skip to the third subsection of section 1 starting "A similar ambiguity..."